laughing_tree: (Default)
laughing_tree ([personal profile] laughing_tree) wrote in [community profile] scans_daily2017-04-09 08:33 am

Astro City #42 - "The Deep Blue Sea"



'Western Detective Fiction thinks Dupin important as he was formative to the genre but does not consider him the paragon of the type. Imagine a world where we could say "Apollo is a more interesting character than Superman" rather than "Apollo is derived from Superman."' -- Kieron Gillen

'I’m trying to imagine a world in which Apollo is more interesting than Superman. No knock on Apollo. But yeah, in other forms, inspiration is a legitimate springboard to creation; in comics it’s looked at askance.' -- Kurt Busiek





















lordultimus: (Default)

[personal profile] lordultimus 2017-04-09 02:09 am (UTC)(link)
To those quotes, I think the problem is that Dupin was only in three stories over a hundred and fifty years ago, while Superman has been a near constant presence for over 75 years in some form or another, especially in the world of comics. It would be far different if, say, Captain Marvel succeeded in eclipsing him in the forties.

[personal profile] palgrave_goldenrod 2017-04-09 02:18 am (UTC)(link)
It's not exactly the same, granted, but if we replace 'Dupin' with 'Sherlock Holmes' then suddenly Gillen's point looks a lot more shaky.

[personal profile] palgrave_goldenrod 2017-04-09 02:26 am (UTC)(link)
Actually, no it doesn't, that is Gillen's point, what on earth am I thinking.
alschroeder3: (Default)

[personal profile] alschroeder3 2017-04-09 04:37 am (UTC)(link)
Another difference is that comic heroes keep on going. Dupin and Sherlock Holmes have their pastiches, but in general the stories of them are done. They're in the past. New characters can evolve as the genre evolve, and they're not stuck in a shared continuity where Dupin is STILL deducting in a modern Paris, Holmes in a modern London. (Well, there's the TV series SHERLOCK, but you know what I mean). Most TV detectives these days are police procedurals, not the hard-boiled detectives of the thirties and forties, much less the eccentric genius of Victorian fiction. Nor are they stuck in a shared universe (unless you're a follower of Wold Newton theories) like most comic book heroes are, where they share a universe with characters conceived in the thirties and forties. They can start again, in the "real" world and take their own tangent---owing the past, but not stuck in it. Unlike comic heroes.
zachbeacon: (Default)

[personal profile] zachbeacon 2017-04-09 04:00 pm (UTC)(link)
I feel like Batman is going to be remembered long after Zorro and Zorro has certainly overshadowed the Scarlet Pimpernel.
glprime: (Default)

[personal profile] glprime 2017-04-10 02:14 am (UTC)(link)
I mean, Batman still incorporates Zorro into his mythos with that origin story of going to the movies (sometimes it's the opera or theatre) and often it's Zorro on the marquee. That always gets me.
q99: (Default)

[personal profile] q99 2017-04-09 04:27 am (UTC)(link)
On the story itself, it's a pretty good one!
icon_uk: (Default)

[personal profile] icon_uk 2017-04-09 07:06 am (UTC)(link)
Agreed, I could sort of see where it was heading early on, but it's a nice journey to get there.
mrstatham: (Default)

[personal profile] mrstatham 2017-04-09 07:46 am (UTC)(link)
This. I've never actually read much of Astro City, only the bits and pieces I've seen on here. It's making me think I should reconsider.

[personal profile] scorntx 2017-04-09 11:18 am (UTC)(link)
You should
burkeonthesly: (Default)

[personal profile] burkeonthesly 2017-04-09 03:25 pm (UTC)(link)
I can honestly say I've never read a bad Astro City. Busiek at his worst is merely middling, and he often finds a way to put heart in the most unexpected places.
q99: (Default)

[personal profile] q99 2017-04-09 10:39 pm (UTC)(link)
And even for Busiek, who's a great writer in general, I think Astro City tends more towards the high end.
zachbeacon: (Default)

[personal profile] zachbeacon 2017-04-09 03:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Astro City #1/2 is free on Comixology. If that doesn't sell you on it then I don't know what will.
q99: (Default)

[personal profile] q99 2017-04-09 10:24 pm (UTC)(link)
It's one of my all-time fav series.
bradygirl_12: (irish ying-yang)

[personal profile] bradygirl_12 2017-04-09 01:08 pm (UTC)(link)
Ha, sometimes solitude is superior to 'civilization'.
domino_blue: (Default)

[personal profile] domino_blue 2017-04-11 06:52 am (UTC)(link)
I don't think it's a very good point Gillen brings up or at least it's not a well thought out one, if you look at characters and stories in other mediums there are characters and concepts that people refer to the originator here's a list.

Movies- Die Hard plot, Ghostbusters,
Anime- Gundam, Fist of the North Star
etc, etc

Hell even comics has it's own derivative characters who are popular, Daredevil would not exist without Spider-man or Spawn with Venom, Saga has been noted to very Star wars but is very unique on it's own. It was a interesting thought until you think about it and he could apply it to more mediums than just comics, whatever becomes the Paragon is often just people gravitating towards a version they like.
domino_blue: (Default)

[personal profile] domino_blue 2017-04-11 01:58 pm (UTC)(link)
To be fair I think some things are weighed down more than others. I remember an anime called Andonah Zero which tried to compete against Gundam and while it was popular for a while it's not talked about in good regard. I just think Gillen thought of it only applying to comics is not true. Spider-man has a lot of Clark Kent in him early on but you rarely hear that he is a complete rip-off of him or burdened by that connection. I think a better argument is that with comics you can trace inspiration very easily since it's a young medium and there have been a lot of writings on it.