Yes, exactly, *thank you.* And it really bugs me when readers take it even one step further and go, "Why don't the writers realize that this character, if they used their abilities *properly* would be able..." and carefully break down how fave *should be* unstoppable, darn it, and the fact the character isn't depicted as such just shows how little imagination and thought is going on in the writing process, etc. etc.
Why assume the writers haven't thought of it? It's more likely that they've thought of exactly this and discarded the notion because they have this funny notion that their stories need to be able to still contain conflict.
I'd say conflict isn't so much the matter as drama. Characters need things
they can't or won't do (unless they're specifically calculating and
ruthless, like Dr. Doom, or Mr. Fantastic, or Darkseid) with their talents
and resources so that the question remains "how will this person deal with
this challenge?" rather than "how would these attributes be most
efficiently used?", the latter of which is best suited for role-playing
games or long conversations on bus rides.
There are many reasonable problems to have with the depiction of a
super-character, that they aren't behaving like a Platonic ideal is not one
of them. Seriously!
In closing, if Scott wants to wear hotpants and nothing else while
reclining on sofas, good for him. I don't just understand, I encourage this
freedom. I respect him for it.
Founded by girl geeks and members of the slash fandom, scans_daily strives to provide an atmosphere which is LGBTQ-friendly, anti-racist, anti-ableist, woman-friendly and otherwise discrimination and harassment free.
Bottom line: If slash, feminism or anti-oppressive practice makes you react negatively, scans_daily is probably not for you.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-25 05:02 am (UTC)Why assume the writers haven't thought of it? It's more likely that they've thought of exactly this and discarded the notion because they have this funny notion that their stories need to be able to still contain conflict.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-25 07:53 am (UTC)I'd say conflict isn't so much the matter as drama. Characters need things they can't or won't do (unless they're specifically calculating and ruthless, like Dr. Doom, or Mr. Fantastic, or Darkseid) with their talents and resources so that the question remains "how will this person deal with this challenge?" rather than "how would these attributes be most efficiently used?", the latter of which is best suited for role-playing games or long conversations on bus rides.
There are many reasonable problems to have with the depiction of a super-character, that they aren't behaving like a Platonic ideal is not one of them. Seriously!
In closing, if Scott wants to wear hotpants and nothing else while reclining on sofas, good for him. I don't just understand, I encourage this freedom. I respect him for it.